Minnesota Supreme Court Deliberates Transgender Athlete's USA Powerlifting Case.

The Minnesota Supreme Court recently convened to hear the case of Jaycee Cooper, a transgender woman who was denied the right to participate in the women’s division of the USA Powerlifting championships. The lawsuit, filed by Gender Justice, claims that USA Powerlifting discriminated against Cooper by refusing her entry to two competitions in 2018 based on her gender identity.

Gender Justice, a legal advocacy group dedicated to supporting transgender rights, argues that USA Powerlifting’s actions contravene Minnesota’s Human Rights Act, which prohibits discrimination based on gender identity.

Jess Braverman, one of Cooper’s attorneys, emphasized that it is a fundamental principle of discrimination law that individuals cannot be excluded or treated differently based on their identity, including transgender women. “This principle applies equally to cisgender women and transgender women,” Braverman stated, asserting the need for the law to be upheld to protect transgender athletes from unfair treatment.

In contrast, USA Powerlifting President Larry Maile defended the organization's decision, claiming that Cooper would have an unfair physical advantage due to her being assigned male at birth. “We welcome all kinds of people to come in, but at the expense of other people, and that's the crux of the issue,” Maile said, further clarifying that while the organization respects people's pronouns and identities, it must preserve fairness in the competition.

USA Powerlifting introduced an open MX division in 2021 to accommodate athletes of all gender identities, including transgender and nonbinary individuals. However, advocates for Cooper and transgender athletes argue that this new division does not address the core issue of transgender women being excluded from women’s competitions. Traci Slane, a coach at Solcana Fitness in Minneapolis, stated, “Inclusion of women is not just some women. It's all women. And trans women are women, hard stop.”

The case has garnered significant attention, not only from the transgender community but from broader civil rights groups. State Senator Erin Maye Quade, who is also a special projects advisor for Gender Justice, criticized USA Powerlifting’s stance, asserting that it marginalizes transgender athletes and undermines their dignity. “Regrettably, USA Powerlifting opted for a different course, one that marginalizes transgender athletes, undermines their dignity, and contravenes Minnesota laws designed to protect them from discrimination,” Quade remarked.

As the Minnesota Supreme Court deliberates, the legal and social implications of this case could have a far-reaching impact on the future of sports and discrimination law, particularly concerning the inclusion of transgender athletes. The outcome of the case is highly anticipated, with advocates from Gender Justice stressing that the decision will not only affect Cooper but could set an important precedent for ensuring equal rights for transgender athletes across the state and beyond.

Braverman expressed optimism for the case, stating, “This case holds significance not only for Jaycee and transgender athletes but for everyone, as it is crucial to ensure that discrimination has no place in Minnesota.” The Minnesota Supreme Court's ruling could potentially redefine the rules of inclusion and fairness in sports for transgender individuals and establish clearer legal protections.

Texas AG Ken Paxton Files Lawsuit Against El Paso Physician Over "Gender Transition" Treatments for Minors